Wednesday, August 09, 2017

Guest Post: The Real Problem Isn't Gender; It's the Modern Media

This guest post by Seth Stephens-Davidowitz was adapted from a comment he wrote on a Facebook post of mine sharing this essay.

While gender in tech is certainly an issue, a lot of the controversy over it is unnecessary. What recently happened with the Google memo is a classic case of Scott Alexander’s Toxoplasma of Rage, one of the most brilliant pieces I have ever read. Read his post. Then read it again.

The stories that go viral are those that maximize anger and foster the most disagreement.

Guy writes a memo with a lot of true statements but an aggressive tone bound to infuriate some people. Within two days, everybody is predictably furious.

My hypothesis is that an overwhelming majority of people actually agree on many of the points of contention--or would agree if they were phrased a little less aggressively, in a tone less likely to create controversy and less likely to go viral.

How many people, for example, agree with the following statement?

"We do not know why CS majors are 80% male. It is possible that, even though millions of women have a passion for computer science, there are, in aggregate, fewer women than men who have this passion. We don't know since computer science is kind of new. And also we don't really understand why female CS majors rose to 40% and then plummeted. Since it is possible that discrimination and stereotypes play a role, we should devote resources to making sure everybody with interest in these high-status jobs has ample opportunity to pursue them. Also, everybody should be judged based on their own interest and aptitude in a job, not how many people of their gender would want that job. Finally, the majority of women in tech--as well as many other high-powered fields--have said they have faced sexism, and we should work really hard to stop that."

This addresses many of the controversies that were raised by the James Damore memo and the responses to it, but is phrased in a way such that few people would find it objectionable. Perhaps we should stop falling for these traps that maximize rage and instead try sober analysis. We may find a surprising amount of consensus.

Lastly, no young person, man or woman, should actually be training for anything--driving cars, teaching kids, diagnosing diseases, or writing programs--because AI will soon do all that for us. ;)

For 352 pages of sober analysis on even more controversial topics, you can check out Seth’s book Everybody Lies.

8 comments:

Pupuk Dasar Tanaman Buncis said...

yeah, we should really really work hard to stop that.

Anonymous said...

I've been thinking how best to start my research paper about problem of gender and growing discrimination in modern society. Thank you for your post and so much important idea that hiding in your title. Really most of the problem it's submission of information in mass media.

Simran Shah said...

Really got a useful blog to read today. Its very informative, keep posting more like this.
Equity Tips

Nat Hill said...

Thanks for the update. I really appreciate the efforts you have made for this blog.
All the best !!!

cheap evening dresses uk
evening dresses under 100
cheap evening dresses under 100

Scarlet Klark said...

Academic writing is clear, concise, focussed, structured and backed up by evidence. Its purpose is to aid the reader’s understanding.
It has a formal tone and style, but it is not complex and does not require the use of long sentences and complicated vocabulary.
Each subject discipline will have certain writing conventions, vocabulary and types of discourse that you will become familiar with over the course of your degree. However, there are some general characteristics of academic writing that are relevant across all disciplines.
Read more about academic writing at https://writingcollegeessays.org

Eaten Turner said...

Hello! What an awesome post! It's great that you have shared it with us. B the way, I know how to help you with the writing papers. Here is one cool writing service that can help you even with the writing jessica mitford behind the formaldehyde curtain or other difficult topics. I hope this information was helpful to you.

Alexa said...

Thank you for sharing us education, please kindly visit mine :D

SITUS JUDI ONLINE RESMI
SITUS POKER ONLINE RESMI
BANDAR POKER ONLINE TERBAIK

Snega Bondato said...

Our accounting homework help is the best homework providing company. We believe that our homework plays an important role in the final grades of students. Due to several reasons, students are unable to write accounting homework. Accounting homework requires accounting homework
remarkable knowledge as well as in-depth understanding of the accounting concepts. Students should get our accounting homework help at our company’s website.

Biology, the study of life, can be fascinating and wondrous. However, certain biology topics can sometimes seem incomprehensible. The best way to get a clear understanding of difficult biology concepts is to study them at home, as well as at school. Students should use quality biology homework help resources when studying. Below are some good resources and information to help you answer some of your obilogy homework questions.